Sound-Image Matching via Semantic Tag Comparison
Continuing development on the Image Extender project, I’ve been exploring how to improve the connection between recognized visual elements and the sounds selected to represent them. A key question in this phase has been: How do we determine if a sound actually fits an image, not just technically but meaningfully?
Testing the Possibilities
I initially looked into using large language models to evaluate the fit between sound descriptions and the visual content of an image. Various API-based models showed potential in theory, particularly for generating a numerical score representing how well a sound matched the image content. However, many of these options required paid access or more complex setup than suited this early prototyping phase. I also explored frameworks like LangChain to help with integration, but these too proved a bit unstable for the lightweight, quick feedback loops I was aiming for.
A More Practical Approach: Semantic Comparison
To keep things moving forward, I’ve shifted toward a simpler method using semantic comparison between the image content and the sound description. In this system, the objects recognized in an image are merged into a combined tag string, which is then compared against the sound’s description using a classifier that evaluates their semantic relatedness.
Rather than returning a simple yes or no, this method provides a score that reflects how well the description aligns with the image’s content. If the score falls below a certain threshold, the sound is skipped — keeping the results focused and relevant without needing manual curation.
Why It Works (for Now)
This tag-based comparison system is easy to implement, doesn’t rely on external APIs, and integrates cleanly into the current audio selection pipeline. It allows for quick iteration, which is key during the early design and testing stages. While it doesn’t offer the nuanced understanding of a full-scale LLM, it provides a surprisingly effective filter to catch mismatches between sounds and images.
In the future, I may revisit the idea of using larger models once a more stable or affordable setup is in place. But for this phase, the focus is on building a clear and functional base — and semantic tag matching gives just enough structure to support that.
